When it comes to make-up, choosing between Catrice and Collistar can depend on various factors: budget, specific needs, and product preferences. Both brands are available on Qathu and offer complete lines for face, eyes, and lips.
This page provides an honest comparison between Catrice and Collistar, with real data on prices, bestsellers, formats, and strengths. The goal is to help you understand which brand suits your make-up needs best.
The products we talk about
Brand positioning and philosophy
Catrice positions itself as an accessible brand, offering a wide range of make-up products for those seeking quality at affordable prices. Collistar, on the other hand, is an Italian brand known for a more selective offering and a mid-to-high price range, focusing on details and formulas.
- Catrice: wide selection and competitive prices
- Collistar: focus on design, selected ingredients, and refined packaging
Price ranges and best-selling products
Prices are one of the main factors that differentiate the two brands. Catrice offers mascaras, lipsticks, and blushes ranging from €6.46 to €11.82. For example, the "Catrice True Skin Concealer 010 Cool Cashmere" costs €6.46, while the "Catrice Magic Shine Eraser Gel to Powder mattifying powder 10 g" is priced at €8.79.
Collistar sits in a higher price bracket: blushes like the "Collistar Impeccable Maxi Blush 9 g" cost €36.43, liquid eyeshadows such as the "Collistar Magnetic Liquid Eyeshadow 03 Hazelnut" are €23.07, and lip glosses are around €23.07.
- Catrice: prices between €6.46 and €11.82
- Collistar: prices between €17.94 and €36.43
Range, formats, and specialties
Catrice offers a very wide collection (over 580 make-up products on Qathu), focusing on lipsticks, mascaras, powders, and blushes in compact and convenient formats. Collistar offers about 400 make-up items, with particular attention to stick and liquid eyeshadows, maxi blushes, and lip glosses, often in generous sizes and elegant packaging.
- Catrice: wide selection of lipsticks and mascaras, compact formats
- Collistar: liquid and stick eyeshadows, maxi blushes, lip glosses
Strengths and who they’re ideal for
Catrice is ideal if you want to build a complete beauty case on a budget without sacrificing variety and trends. Collistar targets those looking for more refined formulas, elegant packaging, and products for sophisticated looks.
- Catrice: suitable for everyday, affordable make-up
- Collistar: perfect for those investing in higher-end products
Summary comparison
| Aspect | Catrice | Collistar |
|---|---|---|
| Price range | €6.46 - €11.82 | €17.94 - €36.43 |
| Best-selling products | Shine Bomb lipsticks, True Skin Concealer, Magic Shine Eraser Powder | Impeccable Maxi Blush, Magnetic Liquid Eyeshadow, Pure Lip Gloss |
| Formats | Compact, practical | Maxi blush, stick/liquid eyeshadows, 5 ml gloss |
| Specialties | Wide range of lipsticks and mascaras | Liquid/stick eyeshadows, maxi blush, gloss |
| Ideal for | Everyday make-up, budget-friendly | Polished looks, selected products |
| Number of products on Qathu | 581 | 405 |
Explore all Catrice and Collistar make-up collections on Qathu · Makeup Catrice (581)
Explore all Catrice and Collistar make-up collections on Qathu · Makeup Collistar (405)
Frequently asked questions
Are Catrice and Collistar cruelty-free?
Information about cruelty-free policies is not provided in the data. Always check the brand’s official website for details.
Which brand has a larger lipstick selection?
Catrice offers a very wide range of lipsticks, with numerous color and finish options.
Are Collistar products suitable for sensitive skin?
No specific claims about suitability for sensitive skin are included in the data. Always check the ingredients list and official info.
Is Catrice suitable for those looking for affordable make-up?
Yes, Catrice stands out for accessible prices and a wide selection of make-up products.
Does Collistar also offer liquid eyeshadows?
Yes, Collistar includes several liquid eyeshadows like the Magnetic Liquid Eyeshadow 03 Hazelnut.
Shipping to over 60 countries from Italy: outside the EU duties and taxes are included in the price (DDP), no surprises at delivery. Returns within 14 days of delivery. Newsletter discount code: 4QATHU. Prices and availability updated on 2026-11-15.